top of page

Restaurant Competitive Threat Assessment

Addendum Form to Competitor Analysis


Business Name

Date Prepared

Prepared By


1. Quick Definitions


Type

Definition

Example

Direct Competitors

Restaurants offering the same cuisine type, price range, and service style to the same target audience in your trade area.

A wood-fired pizza place competing with another two blocks away.

Indirect Competitors

Restaurants or food businesses offering a different cuisine or format but satisfying the same customer need (hunger, occasion, budget).

A pizza place competing with a taco shop or a fast-casual salad spot for the same lunch crowd.





2. Define Your Trade Area


Area Type

Radius / Drive Time

Notes (parking, foot traffic, delivery zones)

☐ Urban

1 mile / 5-minute drive


☐ Suburban

3 miles


☐ Other

______



3. Direct Competitor Capture Grid


Same cuisine, same price tier, same service style, same trade area.



#

Competitor Name

Location / Distance

Price Tier

Why They'd Win a Customer From You

Your Counter-Strategy

1






2






3






4






5







Common Direct Threat Patterns (for reference while filling out above):


Pattern

Example

Why It's a Threat

Same concept, same street

Two Italian trattorias on the same block

Customers choose on small differences — ambiance, wait time, loyalty points

Same cuisine, same price tier

Two mid-priced sushi spots within 1 mile

Customers compare fish quality, service speed, value directly

Chain version of your concept

A local burger joint vs. Shake Shack or Five Guys

Chains have marketing budgets, loyalty apps, predictable quality

Same niche + same vibe

Two plant-based cafés targeting the same audience

Limited core audience — every customer they win is one you lose

Full-service vs. full-service

Two family-style diners with similar menus

Families choose on kids' menu, parking, wait time — not cuisine



4. Indirect Competitor Capture Grid — Same Occasion, Different Cuisine


Different cuisine or craving, but satisfies the same meal occasion.


#

Competitor Name

Occasion (breakfast/lunch/dinner)

Why They'd Win a Customer From You

Your Counter-Strategy

1





2





3






Reference — Occasion-Based Competition:


Occasion

Example

Why They Compete

Casual dinner

BBQ joint vs. Mexican cantina vs. pizza place

"Relaxed dinner out for ~$20/person" — cuisine is secondary to mood/budget

Lunch

Sandwich shop vs. ramen bar vs. salad chain vs. food truck

Office workers have 45 minutes and a set budget — line length and craving decide

Breakfast/brunch

Pancake house vs. bagel shop vs. smoothie bowl café

Morning hunger is format-agnostic — speed and coffee quality drive the decision






5. Indirect Competitor Capture Grid — Same Dollar, Different Format


Different format entirely, but competing for the same customer spend.


#

Competitor / Format

Type (delivery, grocery, meal kit, entertainment, home cooking)

Why They'd Win a Customer From You

Your Counter-Strategy

1





2





3






Reference — Format-Based Competition:


Category

Example

Why They Compete

Full-service vs. fast casual

Sit-down pasta place vs. Chipotle/Cava

Customer wants quick, affordable dinner without tipping

Dine-in vs. ghost kitchen

Your restaurant vs. a delivery-only virtual brand

Customer never leaves home — they compare ETA, fees, packaging

Restaurant vs. grocery prepared foods

Your hot bar vs. Whole Foods hot bar / frozen meals

For solo diners/busy parents, convenience and price win

Restaurant vs. meal kit service

Your specials vs. HelloFresh or local meal prep

Customers seeking convenience/portion control may subscribe instead

Restaurant vs. entertainment venue

Steakhouse vs. movie theater, bowling alley, comedy club

Disposable income is fixed — "experience" competes with "meal"

Restaurant vs. delivery aggregators

Your dining room vs. Uber Eats (even from elsewhere)

Aggregators train customers to stay home — you compete for app attention

Restaurant vs. home cooking

Any restaurant vs. "I'll just cook at home"

Rising costs make this competitor stronger every year

Coffee shop with food

Café selling avocado toast/quiche vs. your breakfast spot

Captures the quick pastry + latte crowd

Bar with kitchen

Craft beer taproom vs. your casual pub

Wins after-work drinks + snack if your food is too formal/expensive

Hotel restaurant (non-guests)

Hotel lobby restaurant vs. your independent bistro

Captures office workers/travelers without needing to advertise





6. Competitive Scoring Matrix


Rate each top competitor 1 (weak) to 5 (strong) per category.


Competitor

Price

Speed

Convenience

Experience

Loyalty / Repeat Business

Total






















Your Restaurant








7. Leak Point Self-Audit


Answer honestly — these are the blind spots most owners miss.


Question

Yes

No

Notes

Do we track sales by daypart (are we losing lunch specifically)?


Do we have a delivery-only / ghost kitchen presence?


Do we compete effectively on speed for the lunch window?


Do we know our answer to "I'll just cook at home" — value, convenience, or experience?


Do we monitor grocery / meal-kit alternatives in our area?


Do we track what % of orders come through delivery apps vs. direct?


Do we have a loyalty program that responds to competitors' programs?


Do we know our hours-of-operation gaps vs. late-night/early competitors?



8. Why This Matters — Strategic Reminders


If you only track direct competitors…

You also need indirect competitors because…

You copy their menu prices.

They capture your customers when you're closed (e.g., late-night taco truck)

You match their portion sizes

They win on convenience (delivery speed, parking, app UX)

You react to their loyalty program

They win on a different craving — customer mood changes daily

You ignore fast-casual or grocery

Your weekday lunch sales erode without you noticing why





9. Top 3 Threats & Action Plan


Rank

Competitor / Threat

Why They're a Risk

Action Item

Owner

Review Date

1






2






3







10. Worked Example (Reference Only)


A mid-priced pizza restaurant (dine-in + takeout)


Direct Competitors

Indirect Competitors

Domino's — same delivery speed, lower price

Chipotle — same lunch budget, different craving

Local wood-fired pizzeria — same price, same street

Ramen shop — same casual dinner mood

Pizza Hut — chain recognition, loyalty app

Grocery store frozen pizza — $6 vs. $22

Another local Italian place — pasta + pizza mix

Burger King drive-thru — speed + convenience


Key takeaway: If you only watch Domino's, you miss that 20% of lost lunch sales went to Chipotle — because they have a mobile order pickup shelf and you don't.


Next Review Date: ____________________ 

Reviewed By: ____________________

bottom of page